Butter Baby Bakery
  • Home
  • Order
    • Signature Design
    • Custom Design
    • Baby Cake
    • Cake Charcuterie
    • EZ-Baby: 2-day notice
    • Stuffed Cupcakes
    • Blondies
  • Inquire
    • Signature Cakes
    • Custom Cakes
    • Baby Cakes
    • Cupcakes
    • Blondies
    • Wedding Cakes
  • Shop
  • More
    • Home
    • Order
      • Signature Design
      • Custom Design
      • Baby Cake
      • Cake Charcuterie
      • EZ-Baby: 2-day notice
      • Stuffed Cupcakes
      • Blondies
    • Inquire
      • Signature Cakes
      • Custom Cakes
      • Baby Cakes
      • Cupcakes
      • Blondies
      • Wedding Cakes
    • Shop

Butter Baby Bakery

  • Home
  • Order
  • Inquire
  • Shop

how to order your custom cake

follow these steps to order your custom cake

step 1: choose your cake flavor

choose option 1 - a collection of our signature flavors

choose option 2 - build your own flavor combination

step 2: choose your size + shape

choose between round / square

choose your size + review price

step 3: fill out custom inquiry form

please provide a color scheme and/or theme

if you have an inspiration photo, please attach it in your form

please note we prefer to take inspiration from photos, and refrain from completely replicating an artists design

 all orders needed for the weekend are required to be submitted by Wednesday.  

custom design process

we design our cakes based on a color scheme and/or theme. every cake is unqiuely designed for each customer based on this. 


we create with buttercream, and do not cover our cakes in fondant. we use minimal fondant for added decor. we do not carve/sculpt or work primarly in fondant.

what comes with your custom design

some if not all will be used in your unqiue design; meringue kisses, crushed meringues, buttercream decor, cake pops, ice cream cake pop, signature sails made of either rice paper, chocolate or wafer paper, handmade chocolate pieces, buttercream florals, edible gold/silver leafing, luster dusting, fresh fruit, and/or colored white chocolate drip or dark chocolate drip.  if you are opposed to certain items please list this in your form.

option 1 - choose a signature flavor

oreo confetti

Oreo Confetti Vanilla Cake filled with creamy Oreo White Ganache

Vanilla crumble

Vanilla Confetti Cake filled with filled creamy cake batter flavored white ganache and vanilla rainbow sprinkle crumble

raspberry love

Vanilla cake studded with fresh raspberries filled with creamy raspberry white ganache, and fresh raspberries

Strawberry Shortcake

Vanilla cake filled with strawberry white ganache, fresh strawberries and vanilla crumble.

Lemon Baby

Vanilla cake, with lemon curd, lemon cream cheese and vanilla crumble

Chocolate Lovers

Chocolate cake with ganache, chocolate cream cheese and crushed malt balls.

ube coconut caramel

Ube cake with coconut caramel ganache with coconut crumble

pecan praline

Browned Butter Vanilla Cake with Pecan Praline Ganache

Cookie Butter

Vanilla cake with biscoff cookie chunks, espresso soak, with cookie butter white ganache

banana caramel

Banana Vanilla Cake with chocolate ganache, caramel and vanilla crumble, brown sugar buttercream

Mocha brownie

Vanilla cake, soaked with espresso simple syrup, espresso infused ganache, and brownie chunks.

pandan-coco

Pandan Cake, pandan infused white ganache, and macapuno strings (coconut jelly).

option 2 - build your own flavor

Build your own flavor from the following items.

cake flavors

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Raspberry Studded Vanilla
  • Cookie Butter Studded Vanilla
  • Oreo Confetti Vanilla
  • Confetti Vanilla
  • Matcha
  • Pandan
  • Ube
  • Vanilla Chocolate Chip
  • Strawberry
  • Blueberry Studded Vanilla

texture add on

  • Crispy Chocolate Pearls
  • Streusel
  • Strawberry Shortcake Crumble
  • Strawberry Crispy Pearls
  • White Chocolate Crispy Pearls
  • Vanilla Streusel Crumble
  • Crushed Malt Balls
  • Pretzels
  • Blondies
  • Brownies

cake Fillings

  • Fresh Mixed Fruit
  • Fresh Strawberries, Blackberries, Blueberries or Raspberries
  • Vanilla Buttercream
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • Espresso Buttercream
  • Cookie Butter Buttercream
  • Brown Sugar Buttercream
  • Nutella Buttercream
  • Oreo Ganache
  • Strawberry Reduction
  • Blueberry Compote
  • Peach Compote
  • PB Buttercream
  • Chocolate Ganache
  • White Chocolate Ganache
  • Strawberry Ganache
  • Caramel
  • Coconut Caramel Ganache
  • Pecan Praline
  • Espresso Ganache
  • Raspberry Ganache
  • Cake Batter White Ganache
  • Cookie Butter Ganache
  • Orange Marmalade
  • Rasp/Straw/Blue Jam

round - single-tiered pricing

All custom cakes comes with some if not all of the following: meringue kisses, crushed meringues, buttercream decor, cake pops, ice cream cake pop, sails made of either rice paper, chocolate or wafer paper, handmade chocolate pieces, buttercream florals, edible gold/silver leafing, luster dusting, fresh fruit, and/or chocolate drip.

4" custom cake

$55

4 - 6 servings

6" custom cake

$110

10 - 14 servings

8" custom cake

$120

16 - 20 servings

10" custom cake

$130

30 - 35 servings


square - single-tiered pricing

4" custom cake

$60

6 - 8 servings

6" custom cake

$120

12 - 18 servings

8" custom cake

$130

20 - 32 servings

10" custom cake

$140

30 - 50 servings


two-tiered pricing

4" + 6"

$170 / $175

Round:  20 - 24 servings

Square: 24 - 26 servings

6" + 8"

$220 / $230

Round: 30 - 35 servings

Square: 32 - 50 servings

8" + 10"

$300 / $310

Round: 40 - 50 servings

Square: 50 - 70 servings


three-tiered pricing

4" + 6" + 8"

$255 / $265

Round: up to 40 servings

Square: up to 60 servings

6" + 8" + 10"

$400 / $410

Round: up to 70 servings

Square: up to 80 servings


four-tiered pricing

4" + 6" + 8" + 10"

$450 / $470

Round: up to 76 servings

Square: up to 108 servings

place your order today

order here

decoration add-ons

Add one of these design add ons to your order.

fresh florals

$20 - $40

boozy shot

$10 - $20

geode + crystals

$15 - $20

Piñata sprinkle center (not available for 4")

$15 - $30

metallic hand painted chocolate drip

$10 - $20

metallic painted decor pieces

$10 - $20

edible image fondant topper

$10 - $20

cake layer add on

Would you like more height + more servings on one tier? Add a single layer plus filling.

one layer add on

$10

This will add 1 - 2 inches of height

two layer add on

$20

This will add 2 - 3 inches of height

three layer add on

$30

This will add 3 - 4 inches of height

order your cake today

order here

Copyright © 2019 ButterBabyBakery - All Rights Reserved.  

  • Shop
  • About us
  • Delivery + Pick up
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions